Choosing hammering tools
The list above is what exists. This is how to decide which of it you actually need, what separates a tool worth keeping from one that ends up at the back of a drawer.
Weight, and why too light is worse
A hammer drives a nail with momentum, so a light hammer needs more blows and a faster swing to do the same work. More blows means more chances to miss, and a fast swing is less accurate than a relaxed one. That is why a 16oz claw hammer is standard rather than a 10oz.
Too heavy is a real limit too, but it arrives later than people expect. A 20oz framing hammer drives a nail in two blows and will tire your forearm over a day, which is a fair trade if you are nailing all day and a bad one if you hang a picture.
- 16oz for general use
- Drives a nail in three blows without wearing you out. The default for a reason.
- 20 to 24oz for framing
- Two blows a nail. Worth the fatigue only if you are nailing all day.
- Light hammers miss more
- More blows and a faster swing. Both reduce accuracy, which is what bends nails.
- Let it fall
- The weight does the work. A relaxed swing hits harder and straighter than a forced one.
Face material decides what you can hit
Steel drives nails and strikes hardened punches. It also splits a wooden chisel handle, mushrooms a plastic one, and dents any finished surface it touches. That is not a quality issue: a steel face is meant to concentrate force.
Soft faces spread it. Wood, rubber, nylon, hide and copper each give up a little energy in exchange for not marking what they hit, which is why assembling a joint, seating a paving slab and driving a chisel all use different faces.
- Steel for nails and punches
- Concentrates force and marks anything it touches. Hardened for hardened steel.
- Wood and resin for chisels
- Broad, softer, spreads the blow. Protects both the handle and the striker's wrist.
- Rubber and nylon for finished work
- Seats and assembles without a mark. Loses energy, which is the point.
- Copper and hide for metal
- Deforms itself rather than the workpiece. Used where a steel dent would matter.
Handle material and shock
Wood absorbs vibration best and breaks. Fibreglass absorbs nearly as much and survives an over strike that would snap hickory. One piece steel is unbreakable and transmits the most shock into your wrist, which matters over hundreds of blows rather than ten.
The failure mode to watch is the over strike: hitting with the handle just below the head. That is what breaks wooden handles, and it is why fibreglass and steel hammers have a collar there.
- Hickory absorbs best
- Kindest on the wrist, and replaceable when it breaks, which it eventually does.
- Fibreglass is the compromise
- Nearly as comfortable and it survives the over strike that snaps wood.
- Steel transmits shock
- Indestructible, and you feel every blow. Fine for occasional use, tiring all day.
- Check the wedge
- A loose wooden head is how a hammer head leaves the handle mid swing.
Hitting it where you meant to
Look at the nail head, not the hammer. Hold near the end of the handle for power and closer to the head for control, and let the weight fall rather than driving it. Most people grip too close to the head and then swing harder to compensate.
Start a nail with a light tap to set it, then swing properly. Nails bend because they were struck off centre or because the timber is hard and the nail was too thin, not because the hammer was too heavy.
- Watch the nail
- Not the hammer. The hand follows the eye, which is why looking at the head works.
- Grip near the end
- For power. Choke up toward the head for accuracy on small work.
- Tap, then swing
- Set the nail with a light blow first so it is standing on its own before the real one.
- Blunt the point in hardwood
- A blunted nail crushes fibres instead of wedging them apart, so it splits far less.
The things that actually go wrong
Hammer injuries are the holding hand, the eye and the back of a loose head coming off. Pliers to hold a small nail solves the first, safety glasses the second, and checking the wedge or the collar solves the third.
The other one is a mushroomed struck tool. A chisel or punch with a spalled end throws steel fragments when hit, and so does a hammer face that has chipped. Both should be ground back rather than used one more time.
- Hold small nails with pliers
- Not fingers. The tap that sets a nail is the blow that catches a thumb.
- Eye protection
- Chipped faces and mushroomed punch ends throw hardened fragments at speed.
- Check for a loose head
- A wooden handle shrinks. A head coming off mid swing travels a long way.
- Never strike two hammers together
- Both faces are hardened. They chip and the pieces leave fast.
Frequently asked questions
- What are the different types of hammer?
- Grouped by what the face is meant to strike. Steel faced claw and ball pein hammers for nails and punches. Wooden and resin mallets for chisels. Rubber and nylon mallets for finished surfaces and assembly. Sledges and club hammers for demolition and masonry.
- What weight hammer should I buy?
- A 16oz claw hammer for general use: heavy enough to drive a nail in three blows and light enough to stay accurate. Go to 20oz or above only if you are framing all day. A hammer that is too light is worse than one slightly too heavy, since it needs more blows.
- What is the difference between a claw hammer and a ball pein hammer?
- A claw hammer has a split claw for pulling nails and is for woodwork. A ball pein has a rounded pein instead and a face hardened to strike other hardened steel, so it is the correct hammer for cold chisels and punches. A claw hammer face can chip on a punch.
- Can I hit a chisel with a claw hammer?
- Not a wood chisel. A steel face splits a wooden handle and mushrooms a plastic one into a burr that eventually breaks off. Use a wooden or resin mallet. Masonry and cold chisels are different, having hardened struck ends made for a club or ball pein hammer.
- Is a wooden or fibreglass hammer handle better?
- Wood absorbs the most vibration and is kindest over a long day, and it breaks on an over strike. Fibreglass absorbs nearly as much and survives that. One piece steel is unbreakable and transmits the most shock. Fibreglass is the usual compromise.
- Why do my nails keep bending?
- Almost always struck off centre, which is a matter of watching the nail head rather than the hammer. Otherwise the nail is too thin for the timber, or the hammer is too light so it takes six blows instead of three and each one is a chance to hit it crooked.
- How do you stop wood splitting when nailing?
- Blunt the nail point with a tap of the hammer first, which makes it crush fibres rather than wedge them apart. Stagger nails so they are not in the same grain line, keep them away from the end of the board, and drill a pilot hole in hardwood or near an edge.
- What is a dead blow hammer for?
- Assembling and seating things without a rebound. The head is hollow and part filled with shot, which shifts forward on impact and kills the bounce. That delivers more of the blow into the work and stops the hammer jumping back at you.